Manual Vs Automatic Transmissions Comparison

It looks like the manual vs automatic transmission debate is never going to end. Though there are many advantages of a manual transmission, it would be wrong to give it the ultimate edge over its counterpart.

Well, when I started I have been advised by my parents that I should learn on manual car, and wouldn’t allow me to drive an automatic until I have become an expert driver. People like both types of transmissions, and claim that advantages one has over the other are unique. Some of their fans claims are not real and totally based on myths.

Let’s go and see how far manual vs. automatic comparison would lead us to solve this sticky situation.

  • Manual transmissions always get better fuel economy’


As we all have grown up having the sentiment that manual gearbox gives better fuel economy rather than automatic but, the automobile manufacturer have managed to solve this issue during the period when the need for combating the hike in fuel prices were on the rise and they succeeded in managing the better fuel economy as new cars are outfitted with additional gears and their mechanism. This shift has become more appreciated because of the better mileage performance. We can observe this performance difference in the 2014 Ford Focus which is well equipped with six-speed automatic transmission giving a better results of (31 mpg combined (27 city/37 highway) than its manual version which gives a 30mpg combined only. It’s another Super Fuel Economy edition proves to be efficient by providing 33 mpg combined fuel economy. To support this there is another excellent example is the 2014 Nissan Versa that proves to be better than 5-speed manual and 4-speed automatic transmissions because of its continuously variable transmission quality that gives 35mpg.

Read Also: Comparison Between Diesel & Gasoline Engine, Which is Better?

  • Stick shift Is less Expensive

This is also partially accurate. Though in some cases the manual versions are cheaper, the trend is declining. Nowadays the practice is to price the both version the same.

Moreover, not every car comes with a manual version.

  • Repairing cost for stick shift is less the Automatic

Although replacing a manual transmission costs less than replacing an automatic, you rarely have to change modern automatic transmissions. In case of manual transmission, you may have to change it once or twice, which costs higher in the long run.

  • Automatic cars are more expensive


In past, we were also having an impression that automatic vehicles cost a lot. By the time we reached in the year 2013, 67% of the cars manufacturers shifted to produce automatics. Even the BMW most manual models were sold at the same price as the manuals. There is another big example of GM’s 2013 Buick Regal GS in this context.

  • Automatics are Easier to Maneuver

The name automatic comes in the mind along with luxury thought that its drive would be easier if there is a straight road and less maneuver is required, No that is not the case actually if the drive is of a manual gear and shifts timely, a better control over the car can be achieved, the driver with a much better command can even fit into a tight parking spot and change direction through potholes with compare to the person who is driving an automatic.

Read Also: Top 5 Best Tips For Buying A Used Car in UAE 2018

  • You Can’t Get The Same Burn Out With Automatic


The reason why the manual cars have been the much preferred among racers for a long time and have an edge over automatic, because if the gears timed correctly, a manual car can have an actual burn out stage to attain swifter head start. However, this concept is also fading away with the revolution in automatic manufacturing cars industries. We can see that change in 2014 Ferrari F12 Berlinetta and the 2013 Maserati Gran Turismo, both come with automatic transmission. These major performance car manufacturers have proved that this myth is also not true anymore.

  • The popularity of Automatic Cars on the Rise All Cars are Available in Automatic Versions

Even though without a doubt, the popularity of automatic cars are on the rise over the years, but we still have much popular cars that come with only standard manual transmission. They are the 2014 Ford Focus ST, the 2014 Ford Shelby GT500, the Volkswagen Golf R and the Audi TT RS. They are operational with stick shifts mechanism only.If you have decided to buy a car and you want to get rid of your old car cashyourcaruae can help you .

  • Power and Climbing

The accurately shifting of manual gears definitely overpowers the capability of the automatic. This strong power makes the manual cars easier to climb steep and mountainous roads.

Read Also: Top 6 Essential Fluids That Your Car needs to Run Smoothly

  • People Prefer to Learn Driving on a Manual


Naturally, the automatic cars are really easy to drive since there is no stick shift and all you need to steer a car and simply concentrate a command over brake and accelerator, whereas teenagers prefer a manual method called a hassle method. As most of the cars available today in automatic transmission have been hassles free so is being avoided by the teenager.